The former framework has been widely used in translation studies, while the latter has been introduced much more recently but is now gaining ground. Yet, ant, also known as the sociology of translation, is not just another. As such, societal order is an effect caused by an actor network running smoothly. Relational materialism actornetwork theory ant is the name given to a framework originally developed by michel callon e.
Are natural resource windfalls a blessing or a curse in democratic settings. Actor network theory and material semiotics john laws. An important goal for the journal is to facilitate publication of the body of research relating to the use of actornetwork theory as. Actornetwork theory and international relationality. An overview of actor network theory3 given this study seeks to appraise the methodological application of ant, it is important that we commence with a detailed overview of this theory. Organization actornetwork theory, organizations and critique. According to jarzabkowski 2010, the actor network theory represents one viable approach for studying how nonhuman artifacts are engaged in strategy as practice. Reassembling the social an introduction to actornetworktheory.
Actornetwork theory ant began at the end of the 1970s as an attempt to account for scientific activity without distinguishing a priori between its socalled social and technical aspects. The international journal of actornetwork theory and technological innovation ijantti publishes research articles covering a wide range of topics related to actornetwork theory ant and its use as a means of exploring sociotechnical phenomena. Latours actor network theory ant is a way of looking at the various systems and environments we encounter in our lives. Secondly, i exam ine why the study of scientific practice, which lay. In so doing, the study aims to contribute to the current dialogue on the potential of ant in the information systems field. Finally, the article examines a number of problems that international relations poses for actornetwork theory. The actornetwork theory latour and woolgar 1986, latour 1987 is a form of constructivism that rejects the idea of a social determination of scientific knowledge, prominent in the edinburgh school, mainly for the reason that the social is barely better understood than the natural. Actornetwork theory ant years ago descriptive theories 1 summary. Actor network theory ant is societys relationship to technology and other nonhuman actor banks, 2011. Actornetwork theory research is an essential resource. Jun 02, 2016 socio material approaches actor network theory and karen barads diffractive methodology duration. Selected papers of the cetra research seminar in translation studies 2008. During the first stage of the research, ant was used to explore how a group of actors.
Actornetwork theory and its role in understanding the. Latour, bruno 1991, technology is society made durable. Scottish graduate school of social science 3,773 views. The publication of bruno latours reassembling the social. Unpacking complexity in public health interventions with the. We argue that health services research, and in particular evaluations of complex it systems in health service organisations, may benefit from being informed by actornetwork theory perspectives. Mack robinson college of business, georgia state university, atlanta, georgia, usa. Reflections on actornetwork theory, governance networks. What are its strengths and limitations as a sociological theory.
Firstly, i consider how the problem of translation has been addressed in actornetwork theory. Understanding the application of actornetwork theory in. This study investigates the potential of actor network theory ant for theory development on information technology project escalation, a pervasive problem in contemporary organizations. Others study the merits of complementing actornetwork theory with additional sociological concepts taken, for example, from bourdieusian field. Ant is a conceptual frame for exploring collective sociotechnical processes, whose spokespersons have paid particular attention to. In what follows first i offer a particular account of the intellectual origins of the actor network approach. Information systems innovation two different models. Footnote 1 for those unfamiliar, reassembling the social charges that sociologys over. All the factors involved in a social situation are on the same level, and thus there are no external social forces beyond what and how the. These data were coded and then analyzed according to the principles of translation as described in actornetworktheory to discover some reasons why certain public programs saw higher attendance from the target population.
Actornetwork theory thus emphasizes the agency of those involved in producing these networks. Latour and callon were also influenced by the angloamerican tradition of microsociology and, although unaware of it at the time, its unacknowledged debts, via the chicago school, to the latenineteenthcentury sociology of gabriel tarde. The paper offers an introductory overview of actor network theory, mapping its relation to and consequent divergence from traditional sociology. In doing so, its advocates define the scope of those agents unusually widely, including nonhuman actants such as scallops, hydraulic doorclosers, and a gamut of other objects and devices that both enable and constrain human activity. This alternative way of practicing sociology has been called actor network theory or ant. From serres, actor network theory borrowed the concept of translation. Actor network theory an overview sciencedirect topics. Second, i characterise what i call actornetwork theory 1990. Network theory for development working paper 5 3 framework callon, 1986 to the case of a new digital technology. In what follows first i offer a particular account of the intellectual origins of the actornetwork approach. Development studies research and actornetwork theory ant4d.
Socio material approaches actor network theory and karen barads diffractive methodology duration. For instance, it is a good idea not to take it for granted that there is a macrosocial system on the one hand, and bits. This study investigates the potential of actornetwork theory ant for theory development on information technology project escalation, a pervasive problem in contemporary organizations. While escalation theory has been used to study runaway it projects. Centre for science studies, lancaster university 3 materials too. Actor network theory ant is a highly influential account within the sociology of science that seeks to explain social order not through an essentialized notion of the social but through the networks of connections among human agents, technologies, and objects. Using actornetwork theory to understand interorganizational network aspects for strategic information systems planning danchao hu february, 2011 master thesis business information technology school of management and governance smg university of twente enschede, the netherlands graduation committee. Actornetwork theory and the ethnographic imagination. Applications within urban living labs of flanders n16 corridor, belgium luuk boelens and marleen goethals. The most widely accepted theory of how technological innovation take place is provided by innovation diffusion. Part of the difficulty of formulating actornetwork theory as a. Powell the logic of position, the measure of leadership position and information in the market forthcoming joel podolny global companies in the 20th century forthcoming leslie hannah. Unpacking complexity in public health interventions with.
Relational materialism actor network theory ant is the name given to a framework originally developed by michel callon e. Cultural translation can draw on several wide notions of translation, particularly as developed in 1 social anthropology, where the task of the ethnographer is to describe the foreign culture, 2 actor network theory translation sociology, where the interactions that form networks are. The process by which an actor joins a network is seen as an act of translation. Understanding the application of actornetwork theory in the. Dec 02, 2011 actor network theory ant is societys relationship to technology and other nonhuman actor banks, 2011. Actornetwork theory ant is an increasingly influential, but still deeply contested, approach to understand humans and their interactions with inanimate objects. This book employs actor network theory ant to explore the making of the english translation of a work of chinese canonical fiction, journey to the west, demonstrating how ant, as applied to translation studies, can contribute to a richer understanding of the translation process. A comparison of bourdieusian field theory and actornetwork theory in translation sociology. Ant, as proposed by callon 1986, law 1986 and latour 1987, is a social theory which originated in the field of science and technology. Both actor network theory and group analysis, then, deal with matters of identity and change within speci. An introduction to actornetworktheory was a remarkable event, which capitalized on the steadily growing interest in the works of latour, callon, law, mol, and others assembled, willfully or not, under the label actornetwork theory ant.
Reassembling the social an introduction to actornetworktheory bruno latour science, innovation, and economic growth forthcoming walter w. Reassembling the social an introduction to actor network theory bruno latour science, innovation, and economic growth forthcoming walter w. Actor network theory addresses the coevolution of interactants in a locale, or actors in a network, in a way that was useful in the analysis of this research. Reflections on actornetwork theory, governance networks, and. Bringing actornetwork theory to it project escalation studies. Actornetwork theory is a framework and systematic way to consider the infrastructure surrounding technological achievements.
Social enterprises are companies that use marketbased revenues to generate social value while maintaining financial viability. If you see a topic that doesnt seem right for this content, flag it below and well take a look. In actor network theory ant, translation is the process that allows a network to be represented by a single entity, which can in itself be an individual or another network. Actor network theory ant is an increasingly influential, but still deeply contested, approach to understand humans and their interactions with inanimate objects.
Organization actornetwork theory, organizations and. An important goal for the journal is to facilitate publication of the body of research relating. How do translators and the other actors involved in translation create meaning in the situations and texts they handle. Description the international journal of actornetwork theory and technological innovation ijantti publishes research articles covering a wide range of topics related to actornetwork theory ant and its use as a means of exploring sociotechnical phenomena.
Starting from the new insights of science studies, we have since explored many other domains from technology to health, from market organisations to art, from religion to law, from management to politics. Finally, the article examines a number of problems that international relations poses for actor network theory. Notes on urban studies, actornetwork theory and geographical scale alan latham and derek mccormack. While stressing the need to safeguard and promote the study of foreign languages, damrosch also. Actornetwork theory ant and a practicebased approach pba, both members of the praxeological family of theories reckwitz, 2002, were used in sequential order to inform the analyses. Indeed, actornetwork theory should not be understood as a body of theory that can be simply applied to a range of empirical examples. Indeed, actor network theory should not be understood as a body of theory that can be simply applied to a range of empirical examples. Another approach however, that of innovation translation which draws on the sociology of translations, more commonly known as. Firstly, i consider how the problem of translation has been addressed in actor network theory. You form an actor network taking the shortcut in the studies that someone else has had. This is the version, with all its strengths and weaknesses, that. Actornetwork theory ant is a theoretical and methodological approach to social theory where everything in the social and natural worlds exists in constantly shifting networks of relationships. These new topics are drawn from a thesaurus curated from 21 source vocabularies, and are automatically matched with a brief description from wikipedia. According to jarzabkowski 2010, the actornetwork theory represents one viable approach for studying how nonhuman artifacts are engaged in strategy as practice.
Actornetwork theory as an approach to social enterprise and. Ant has its origins in an attempt to understand science. These studies no matter how interesting concerns themselves. Ant which is most commonly associated with science and technology studies but has implications outside of simply the analysis of scientific and technical practices. Bringing actor network theory to it project escalation studies. Actornetwork theory, ant and after, critical performativity, management and organization. Actor network theory ant is an approach to doing sociological analysis.
Further back still a different kind of actor was introduced in the form of the postal system or perhaps the postal worker who enabled. Actor network theory actor network theory ant, also known as enrolment theory or the sociology of translation, emerged during the mid1980s, primarily with the work of bruno latour, michel callon, and john law. Pdf this study of resistance to multinational mining in new caledonia expands actornetwork theorys concept of translation by exploring ways that. Cognitive scientific approaches to translation try to understand and explain the workings of translators minds. In actornetwork theory ant, translation is the process that allows a network to be represented by a single entity, which can in itself be an individual or another network in 1986, michel callon published the seminal article some elements of a sociology of translation, in which he summarized the process of translation as four moments or phases. Using coevolutionary actor network theory as a prospective methodology tsehui the, 14. Entities whether human or nonhuman within those networks acquire power. Actornetwork theory as an approach to social enterprise.
In the fourth translation, the actors associate without losing their identity. An actornetwork theory analysis of policy innovation for. A brief summary of actor network theory cyborgology. The actor network theory latour and woolgar 1986, latour 1987 is a form of constructivism that rejects the idea of a social determination of scientific knowledge, prominent in the edinburgh school, mainly for the reason that the social is barely better understood than the natural. This thesis assesses the potential of actor network theory ant for conceptualising social enterprise by applying the concepts of assemblage and translation to the production of social values through three fieldsites studied in ghana. Actor network theory thus emphasizes the agency of those involved in producing these networks. If we want to understand the mechanics of power and organisation it is. Topics provide a way to find more content about a subject and do targeted searching on jstor. Ant focuses on sciencebased innovation processes, and, in analyzing indoor smokefree regulations, the process necessitates engagement with all the component subsystems tobacco control, tobacco industry, regulatory, and tobacco use of the tobacco use management system 2 as well as relevant features of their context that together determine tobacco use. This study displays all the ingredients of actornetwork theory 1990. This thesis assesses the potential of actornetwork theory ant for conceptualising social enterprise by applying the concepts of assemblage and translation to the production of social values through three fieldsites studied in ghana.
Actor network theory has elaborated a whole lexicon of terms to document and analyse the moves in this process, including enrolment, translation, association and interest. We argue that health services research, and in particular evaluations of complex it systems in health service organisations, may benefit from being informed by actor network theory perspectives. Another approach however, that of innovation translation which draws on the sociology of translations, more commonly known as actor network theory ant, also has much to offer. Actor network theory claims that any actor, whether person, object including computer software, hardware, and technical standards, or organization, is equally important to a social network. There is tension because actors have their own interests and translation plays a vital role in acquiring stability among this chaos. Second, i characterise what i call actor network theory 1990. Latour french sociologist of science influential theorist in sts developer of ant influenced by harold garfinkels ethnomethodology, generative semiotics of griemas and maverick sociology of gabriel tarde. It posits that nothing exists outside those relationships. Put simply, ant is the theory that actants, human and nonhuman, both possess the same level of agency to make up a network. The sociology of translation technopolitics and sociotechnical relations re. Centre for science studies, lancaster university 2 here is the argument.
From serres, actornetwork theory borrowed the concept of translation. If we want to understand the mechanics of power and organisation it is important not to start out assuming whatever we wish to explain. It first proposes three arguments in favour of using the actornetwork theory ant for the framework. Actornetwork theory ant is a theoretical orientation based on the ontology of relational. It is important to clearly define what we mean by social. Actor network theory ant is a theoretical and methodological approach to social theory where everything in the social and natural worlds exists in constantly shifting networks of relationships. Obviously, there is more to translation than just associating words in one language with those in another. An introduction to actornetwork theory actornetwork theory emerged from the field of science and technology studies during the 1980s, particularly associated with the work of three academics. In this lesson, we will discuss what the theory proposes, and how we.
337 398 1214 89 927 1416 1172 908 961 1295 569 1324 1431 408 1167 1132 1209 1432 747 1491 928 1439 881 960 807 1420 328 1036 545 1017 405 1399 776 929 8 467 902 1285